Diane Ravitch, in her article, "The Biggest Fallacy of the Common Core Standards", talks about how the Common Core standards are not a good idea. She says that the only reason most states opted to adopt these standards was because of the promise of money from the Obama Administration. She does not agree with the standards and says that they have nothing to do with getting a student ready for a career even though they are college and career readiness oriented standards. She also claims that, if anything, these standards are discouraging students from pursuing careers in areas such as science and math because and driving them to look at easier courses. She also talks about how the failure rate of these tests are very high and that most students are more likely to give than to try harder. She also talks about how much money it takes to implement the new testing procedures and says that this money could be better spent elsewhere.
I do not think that anything that destines students to fail, whether purposefully or not, should be implemented in our education system. Every student deserves a chance to thrive and succeed and anything that takes this chance away from them should be done away with. Students in one area or state may learn differently from those in another, so who are we to say that they should be given the exact same material and tested in the exact same way? Those that learn differently would just have the odds stacked against them. If these standards are really as bad as some people make them out to be, then I don't think they are such a good idea, either. However, I will gather my own research and make a decision for myself when i am more informed.
When I read through your response, I noticed that you caught a few additional things that I had not noticed, such as the fact that students will be deterred from pursuing math and science because they will be looking for something easier. Very well summarized.
ReplyDeleteHowever,
I noticed that you used the phrase "She also talks about.." several times. In your next posts, try to stay away from using the same combination of words over and over again.
Very good summary Amanda. You made me remember exactly which article that you were talking about and reminded me in your opinion that I did not agree with it either. I thought it was cool how you mentioned that people across the nation may learn differently or just not be taught properly at all, and then to test them on something that they may or may not know based on something out of their control is wrong. I think your opinion is really well thought out and accurate, especially by saying that you were going to get more informed on this topic. I enjoyed reading it!
ReplyDelete